By Martin Whitely
Perth’s ADHD generation, those diagnosed and ‘medicated’ in the 1990’s and early 2000’s, are now young adults. They were prescribed ADHD amphetamines (primarily dexamphetamine) at three to four times the rate of their eastern states contemporaries1 and old habits die hard. Many of Perth’s twenty to early thirty-somethings have grown to love their ‘dexies’, particularly with a drink or fifteen, on their weekend benders. With dexies on board they drink longer and harder, with the loss of inhibition and impaired judgement from alcohol but without the drowsiness. Some also use dexies as a substitute for sleep, to either get up for work after a hard night of partying, or to cram for exams or tight work deadlines.
Part of the problem is that whilst methamphetamine is illegal in Australia and therefore understood to be harmful, it’s difficult to get Perth’s ‘dexie generation’ to realise that dexamphetamine is not a benign substance. It might help if we point out that methamphetamine (brand name Desoxyn) is a legally prescribed ADHD treatment in the US. Then again it might simply normalise the use of methamphetamine.
But as it stands many of Perth’s young adults love their dexamphetamine. Despite the fact that the ‘near amphetamine’2 methylphenidate (Ritalin, Concerta) is the most commonly prescribed ADHD stimulant in Australia, (73% of all scripts)3, the vast majority of both new (82.5%) and continuing (86.6%) WA adult patients prescribed ADHD stimulants take dexamphetamine.4 Many get dexamphetamine rather than Ritalin, because they ask for it and they ask for it because dexies are the recreational prescription stimulant drug of choice amongst Perth’s hard partying young adults.
Perth’s rise in adult ADHD prescribing rates defies the trend for kids. WA’s child ADHD per capita rate has plummeted (approximately 50%) since tighter prescribing accountability measures were introduced in late 2003,5 while the number of adults prescribed stimulants (primarily dexamphetamine) has risen 57% since 2004, so that in 2011 there were 9,846 WA adults on prescription stimulants.6
I am not suggesting that all of these adult patients are intentional ADHD drug abusers. Some of these are carryover ‘patients’ from the ‘dexie generation’; who still believe the ‘ADHD chemical imbalance’ lie they, and their parents, were told when they were children. Other former child patients have become physically and psychologically dependent as predicted on the manufacturer’s guidelines 7 that many of their parents never even had the opportunity to read.8
Some new adult patients genuinely believe they have a ‘biochemical brain imbalance’ and mistakenly believe the almost universal upper effect of dexamphetamine is peculiar to ADHD. However, there is a new group of young adult ‘dexie’ users, who have learned how to tick the right ADHD boxes and say the right things to the handful of enthusiastic Perth prescribers. (In 2009 six WA doctors prescribed to over 500 patients each with the heaviest prescriber prescribing to a staggering 1,360 patients.)9 As a result they and their friends have got a convenient taxpayer subsidised supply of ‘uppers’ and can party all weekend and wake up bright as a button for work on Monday morning.
Faking ADHD is not a uniquely West Australian experience. Recent US research revealed nearly a quarter of all adults seeking treatment for ADHD feigned symptoms to get a cheap supply of amphetamines.10 And you would be mistaken if you thought that this didn’t happen in nice homes and good neighbourhoods. Whilst its child prescribing rates are now relatively low, the Oceanic Health District, which covers Perth’s affluent western suburbs, easily has the highest adult ADHD per capita prescribing rates in Australia’s highest (adult) prescribing state (WA).11 This may in part be a legacy of the fact that Perth’s western suburbs and the less prosperous south east corridor around Armadale were the two child ADHD hotspots in the 1990’s.12
Unfortunately there is little direct data as to how prevalent the abuse of ADHD amphetamines is by WA adults. But we know from surveys that the vast majority of high school students who have abused amphetamines have abused prescription ADHD amphetamines.13 Now it’s time to ask how much of Perth’s spate of alcohol related violence is also fuelled by amphetamines, and how much diverted dexamphetamine contributes to this problem.
Whilst at last we are slowly awakening to the ADHD fraud, we are still reluctant to blame the doctors who prescribe these poisons,14 for a disorder that was voted into existence by a panel of self-appointed mostly drug company funded ‘experts’.15 But ADHD prescribers are practising quackery not medicine, and that makes them quacks not doctors, and it is time we said so.
So before we middle aged West Australians bemoan the decadence and decay of youth, remember, it was our generation who put them on this pathway. Too many of our generation unquestioningly accepted the ADHD industry nonsense that, just like diabetes or cancer, ADHD is a disease requiring ‘medication’. Even now it is our generation’s leaders that finds the truth – i.e. ADHD is a dumbed down, unscientific, catch all diagnosis and amphetamines are bad for kids – too confronting to say out loud.
We can’t leave our head in the sand any longer. All the available evidence suggests Perth’s twenty to early thirty-somethings have a large and growing dexamphetamine habit. They get it, they abuse it, they drink too much, they fight too much and tragically some die too early.16 And it is not their generation’s fault, it is my generations, because when they were kids, we were their dealers.
- Martin Whitely, Speed Up & Sit Still: The Controversies of ADHD Diagnosis and Treatment, UWA Publishing (2010): p.126. ↩
- Martin Whitely, Speed Up & Sit Still: The Controversies of ADHD Diagnosis and Treatment, UWA Publishing (2010): p.34 ↩
- Statistics relate to 2010 calendar year and were obtained from the Medicare Australia website, Available at https://www.medicareaustralia.gov.au/statistics/pbs_item.shtml ↩
- Department of Health, (2010), Western Australian Stimulant Regulatory Scheme 2009 Annual Report, Pharmaceutical Services Branch, Health Protection Group, Department of Health, Western Australia pp. 38-43. http://www.public.health.wa.gov.au/cproot/3605/2/Annual_Report_2009.pdf ↩
- See ‘Rise and fall of child ADHD in WA’, http://speedupsitstill.com/rise-and-fall-of-child-adhd-in-wa ↩
- Department of Health, Western Australian Stimulant Regulatory Scheme 2011 Annual Report, Pharmaceutical Services Branch, Health Protection Group, Department of Health, Western Australia (2012):p20 http://www.public.health.wa.gov.au/cproot/4883/2/stimulant-annual-report-2011.pdf ↩
- The warning issued by the manufacturer concerning amphetamines, such as Dexedrine, and their high potential for abuse can be found on the US Food & Drug Administration website http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/drugsatfda_docs/label/2006/017078s040lbl.pdf ↩
- It is a legal requirement that Consumer Medicine Information (CMI) sheets are available for all prescription (S4 and S8) and pharmacist-only (S3) medicines, however there is no requirement that they must be provided with each prescription ↩
- Department of Health, Western Australian Stimulant regulatory Scheme: 2009 Annual Report, Pharmaceutical Services Branch, Environmental Health Directorate, Department of Health, Western Australia (210):p8 http://www.public.health.wa.gov.au/cproot/3605/2/Annual_Report_2009.pdf ↩
- Meredith Melnick, ‘Faking It: Why nearly 1 in 4 adults who seek treatment don’t have ADHD’, Time Healthland, 28 April. Available http://healthland.time.com/2011/04/28/faking-it-why-nearly-1-in-4-adults-who-seek-treatment-dont-have-adhd/ (accessed 24 May 2011) ↩
- Department of Health, Western Australia Stimulant Regulatory Scheme 2008 Annual Report, Pharmaceutical Services Branch, Health Protection Group, Department of Health, Western Australia (2009): p28 ↩
- The Report of the Technical Working Party on Attention Deficit Disorder to the Cabinet Sub-Committee, Parliament House Western Australia, 1997, p. 6 ↩
- A 2005 survey of Western Australian secondary school students (the Australian School Students Alcohol and Drug Survey or ASSAD) found that 84 per cent of those who had abused amphetamines in the last year had abused prescription amphetamines. Drug and Alcohol Office WA, ASSAD Drug Report 2005, Mt Lawley, March 2007, pp. 30-32. ↩
- A Stimulant Regulatory Scheme was established in August 2003, with the legislative framework for the Scheme contained in the Poisons Regulations 1965. Under the Scheme, the Stimulant Prescribing Code sets out the criteria for the prescribing of stimulant medicines in WA. ↩
- Martin Whitely, Speed Up & Sit Still: The Controversies of ADHD Diagnosis and Treatment, UWA Publishing (2010): p.7. ↩
- For further information see ‘Claire Murray (14 March 1985 – 1 April 2010) – A casualty of Perth’s Generation deX’, available at http://speedupsitstill.com/claire-murray-casualty-perths-generation-dex ↩
Tags: Dexamphetamine abuse, faking ADHD, methamphetamine and ADHD, Perth Dexamphetamine
Martin ,you have identified the missing piece of the jigsaw. People wonder why violence has increased in Perth nightspot areas. Alcohol consumption is static. When people are drunk their capacity to fight is reduced even if their desire to is increased. Mix in amphetamines and people the have desire and the capability.
Martin, this is a very well-written piece. Many are sure to attack you simply because they will be unable to address your sound reasoning. What I find most encouraging (admidst the despair) is that people are starting to realise that the ADHD show does lack scientific backing.
Spot on Martin, but amphetamines combined with drinking and addiction to harder drugs are only some of the long term effects, in my opinion. Think of all the resources and wider social implications this will have on the general public. Not to mention immediate family members.
Hello my names wade I’m 21 years old I think you make a strong point on the subject but for those genuines who suffer from ADHD like myself it angers me when others lie just to get an easy substituate for drugs its like someone saying they have cancer when they dont the prescribed dexamphetime is a usefull tool for everyday life it gives me balance to concentrate and focus on the important things at hand I’ve recently been prescribed concerta and hope the effects are better improved what I’m trying to say is for those like myself who need it the possitive outcomes are tremendously positive and uplifting its helped me deal with life thanks for your time
Hi. As a twenty-something year old currently prescribed for ADD, my experience with the medical world confirms your fears about rampant over-prescription by the aging “quacks”, who seem to be lacking the ability or inclination to properly help people who approach them with a genuine concern about their mental health.
I know dexamphetamine is an ill-fitting bandaid measure for my complaints due to the number of side-effects I put up with, but I have actually found it fairly difficult to find good help – everyone just wants to give me dexies or antidepressants! I now find myself begrudgingly taking my prescribed medication only when necessary, around experimenting with nutrition/sleep/exercise combinations in my spare time…
If you know of any practitioners who are actually interested in their field beyond playing “pin the medication on the symptom”, (or inversely, implying that I’m simply imagining things), I would definitely appreciate the tip-off.Concerta works good for me don’t no what your problem is
I think you will find ADHD is not a lie.
This may look like a scientific piece of writing but there is only ONE psychologically relevant article being referenced that is not the authors own work. This single article is not even a psychological study, nor is it relevant to Australia. Your numbers may be correct (pulled from government websites) but your inferencing is fallacious. To go as far as declaring ADHD a fallacy is misinformed and shows a complete lack of sensitivity for those that struggle with it. Perhaps next you will tell us all how hysteria is just a disturbance of the womb.
To all those reading this, please think for yourselves. Every article you ever come across, just do a little analysis, the most basic of checks is reliable sources, any first year university student will know that.
Just because an article is well written (I will give you that), does not mean that the overall message of the piece is true.
Jane rather than take some mysterious detour regarding hysteria (about which I have no knowledge or interest) lets stick to ADHD.
I agree that “all those reading this” piece or any piece on ADHD should “think for themselves” and add they should never lose sight of two indisputable facts:
1- The diagnostic criteria of ADHD are behavourial and despite frequent promises of imminent diagnostic breakthroughs there are no objective biological diagnostic tests for ADHD. The 18 behaviours listed in the diagnostic criteria are normal childhood (and adult) behaviours including disliking homework, avoiding chores, being forgetful and easily distracted, fidgeting and interrupting.
These are the sorts of things most kids particularly boys will do when taught by boring, incompetent teachers or poorly parented (politically incorrect to say but perfectly true). Some kids do have real issues but the dumbed down ADHD label combined with numbing medication masks these issue. At the extreme end I know of a number of cases of children who have been raped and traumatised by adults they should be able to trust and then violated again with amphetamines by useless dangerous quacks.
2- Ritalin, Concerta, Adderall, dexamphetamine and all the ADHD stimulants are all either amphetamines or amphetamine like substances that are Schedule 8 drugs (schedule II in the US) because they are addictive with a high potential for abuse. (If you don’t believe me check the manufacturers own literature).
A lot of adults who think they have ADHD like how low dose amphetamines make the feel. They do temporarily narrow focus and many gullible people mistakenly believe this is evidence their “biochemical brain imbalance” has been “balanced” i.e. their ADHD has been treated. The dependence can therefore become both psychological and physical.
I think that if an adult wants to take amphetamines because they like how it changes them we should all at least be honest enough to admit that is what they are doing and stop pretending they have a disease that is a legitimate as diabetes.
1. Strawman argument; the diagnostic criteria for autism spectrum disorders are also behavioural and there is no biological test for autism – are you saying that autism does not exist? Similarly, most if not all of the behaviours of anxiety-linked psychiatric disorders (e.g., obsessive compulsive disorder, generalised anxiety disorder, etc.) feature ‘normal’ behaviours (relative to their cohort); the difference between ‘normal’ and ‘abnormal’ being the nature, frequency, and impairment to daily functioning. For example, you could say that avoiding chores is a normal behaviour, sure. However, to continue to avoid chores despite serious consequences to relationships and functioning (e.g., not working on an important document even with the threat of being fired from ones’ job) rests high on the normal-abnormal continuum.
I think you will find in the body of peer-reviewed psychological literature that ADHD is not a “dumbed down label” but a problem marked by dysregulated inhibitory control processes and persisted cognitive hyperarousal. Please provide evidence contrary to this body of literature and I’m sure your readers would be interested in reading.
2. “Stimulant medications are classified as ‘drugs of addiction’ under NSW law and have the potential to be abused. When taken as prescribed – orally and in a therapeutic dose – stimulants do not induce euphoria and are unlikely to lead to abuse.” Second sentence is relevant to your argument, taken from NSW department of public health (http://www0.health.nsw.gov.au/PublicHealth/Pharmaceutical/adhd/faqs.asp#para_4).
“With regards to your comments about avoiding chores. One of my now adult children expends considerable energy avoiding chores (as did I until middle age) and it often leads to frequent arguments and on occasions damage to relationships. That does not make him or I psychiatrically disorded just lazy, inconsiderate and unmotivated. We need to stop trying to medicalise every imperfect human behaviour.”
The presence of ‘conditions & disorders’ are exactly what makes us who we are. Its not to say that its imperfect, just different. Because some people (myself included) are unable to apply ourselves to work, study or chores without stimulants then such a disorder clearly exists. Whether you choose to acknowledge that or not is you choice, but its ignorant not to considering it may come at the cost of your childrens full potential. People are the way they are for a reason, and in true cases of ADHD it is definitely a neurochemical imbalance.
i self diagnosed at age 24 at one point id stoped taking dex during IVF and didnt get back to them for 12 years 45+ year old i dont drink or smoke at all ,you lot are are wasting your time trying to convince each other that your view is the right one .but here i go any how.lol, circular logic +narrominded+ self rightness+ego+ignorance. ECT ECT. for me the dex works ,as for people quoting statistics from here or there , its the general incompetence of the medical system that is at fault not the medications. .why pick on the ADD drugs ,children are exposed to the addictions of alcohol and cigarettes daily, but because many people have been brain washed over the decades to think these things as socially acceptable, and even a right to fight for , they are going under the radar , coupled with the fact that those two things most of the time kill much more slowly and make a few bucks for the governments there not looked at to hard. do we stop treating people for cancer because some of the ..people dye from the treatment . shall we ban guns because people kill people with them. criminals still get weapons and drugs regardless of there legal state . >>>>>>> indisputable facts. this statment on this topic only heigh -lights the incompetence of the medical system. a great many things touted as fact have over time found to be wrong at some point in the future. ((( A lot of adults who think they have ADHD like how low dose amphetamines make the feel. They do temporarily narrow focus and many gullible people mistakenly believe this is evidence their “biochemical brain imbalance” has been “balanced” i.e. their ADHD has been treated. The dependence can therefore become both psychological and physical. ))) and the same is true for alcahol and cigerets …
Your claim that many young adults in Perth ask for dex over Ritalin is based in what evidence? Have you bothered to consider the cost differential? Probably not. It would matter little to you I think. You’re clearly of the view the ADHD is a fantasy disorder.
People who are struggling to get recognition and treatment should not be disheartened by reading this rubbish article.
Martin, 1) dexamphetamine is a small fraction of the cost of the drugs still under patent for the treatment of ADHD (and other psycho-stimulants).
2) Dexamphetamine is prescribed for many conditions other than ADHD. Some have a psychiatric component, many are “physical”.
3) Your apparent abhorrence of drug abuse is a common and respected position however, we do not try and demonize young adults who have had to use pain killers or other drugs of addiction whilst growing up. Is it because we cant “see” the pain inflicted by ADHD and ADD etc that make sufferers easy targets?
4) I am a retired scientist and have no association with ADHD. Most young people today appear to me to be more socially and environmentally responsible than our generations. I take exception to you trying to maliciously burden generations with outrageous labels (“Perth’s ADHD generation”) and to try and imply that a significant number of young people (“many”) illegally use dexamphetamine.
5) This is a form of bullying that appeals to rednecks and to those who will always only “harvest low hanging fruit and leave the rest to rot”.


sending...
20 comments
Comments feed for this article